Connected watch or children's smartphone: what to choose for Christmas?

Reading: 6 min

Summarize this article

Save time by using AI to summarize this content.

The main thing to remember

  • In primary school, a 4G connected watch is often enough to remain reachable and localizable, without internet or social networks.
  • In middle school, a smartphone secure with modular parental control meets broader needs.
  • The transition from the watch to the smartphone can be done smoothly, by adding applications over time.
  • Both a 4G watch and a smartphone require a SIM card and a plan: a point to integrate into the budget.
  • NEOW offers the two stages: connected watches for children and the NEOW Safe with Éos Neow, free and without subscription.

Connected watch or smartphone for a child: the right choice depends above all on their age, their journeys and their needs. In primary school, a 4G connected watch is most often sufficient; in college, a first secure smartphone takes over. Age benchmarks, comparison table and practical points (package, school, private life) to choose with peace of mind at Christmas.

Connected watch or smartphone: as Christmas approaches, many parents hesitate between these first two devices. The right choice depends above all on the age of your child, their journeys and their needs. Here are some simple guidelines.

Connected watch or smartphone: the answer depending on the age of your child

In primary school, a connected watch is most often sufficient; in college, a first secure smartphone takes over when needs expand. There is no official age: these benchmarks are starting points, to be adjusted according to the maturity of your child.

  • Before 8 years old : a personal device is rarely useful. The child is almost always accompanied.
  • From 8 to 10 years old : a 4G connected watch responds well to the first journeys alone (school, activities). He remains reachable, without internet or social networks.
  • From 10 to 12 years old, around the start of 6th grade : the watch remains a good option if the child mainly needs to call. A secure smartphone becomes relevant if they need to consult their timetable or communicate with their class.
  • From 12-13 years old : a smartphone with adjustable parental controls, the framework of which becomes more flexible over time.

To go further: At what age should you give your child a phone.

Comparison table: connected watch or secure smartphone

The connected watch is mainly used to remain reachable and locatable; the secure smartphone gradually opens the door to applications, within a framework chosen by the parent.

Criterion 4G connected watch Secure smartphone
Calls and messages Yes, with contacts validated by parents Yes, with communication applications allowed
GPS and geolocation Yes, depending on models Yes, depending on parental control settings
Safety zones On certain models Depending on the application used
Button SOS Yes, on many models No dedicated button
Internet and social networks No free navigation Access adjustable by the parent
Applications None or very few Added according to age and needs
School mode Class mode on many models Screen time adjustable by the parent
SIM card and plan Necessary for 4G Necessary
Ideal use First trips alone, primary school College, greater autonomy

With NEOW : a watch to start, a secure smartphone for the rest

If you are looking to make your child contactable without giving them internet too early, the connected watches for children from the NEOW range are designed for this. The 4G models allow voice and video calls with a contact list validated from the parent application, offer an SOS button and a class mode which limits the watch during classes. Free internet browsing and social networks are not available by default. The benefit: your child gains autonomy, and you maintain a simple link with him.

When your child needs more, the secure smartphone NEOW Safe takes over with Éos Neow, parental control NEOW, always free and without subscription. You validate each new application, adjust screen time by app or category and can block access to the internet and search engines. Content filtering and geolocation on demand complete this controlled digital framework, which evolves with age. NEOW is a French brand, chosen by more than 30,000 users across the brand.

Then, a watch without a SIM card like the W-Watch can accompany the smartphone: it pairs via Bluetooth to the phone to receive call and message notifications.

What a connected watch allows, and its limits

A connected watch allows the child to call, be called and alert quickly, without an invasive screen: a first step towards autonomy to go to school alone or warn of a delay.

Depending on the models, it also offers a pedometer to monitor physical activity, good waterproofing (IP68 on several models) and a rechargeable battery. Battery life varies depending on the model.

According to WatchGeneration, 2026, sales of connected watches for children will more than double in France in 2025.

Its limits appear in middle school: no access to the online timetable or group exchanges with the class.

Key figures

  • More than double : sales of connected watches for children will more than double in France in 2025 (WatchGeneration, 2026).
  • IP68 : waterproof level of several models of connected watches for children.
  • More than 30,000 users across the brand NEOW.

When to switch from a watch to a smartphone

The right time to switch to a smartphone comes when your child needs tools that the watch doesn't offer, not just when he asks for them. Some signs: longer journeys, the need to talk with friends or consult Pronote.

A gradual transition makes this passage more peaceful. Some parents start with a smartphone with few apps, then add more over the months, setting the rules together. To compare the selection criteria, our guide to choosing your first phone details the points to look at.

Subscription, school and private life: points to check

Before offering one or the other device, three practical points should be looked at: the package, the rules of the establishment and the protection of data.

The plan. A 4G watch needs a nano SIM card and a mobile plan, often not included, just like a smartphone. The budget therefore includes the price of the device and the monthly subscription.

School and college. Article L511-5 of the Education Code prohibits students from using a mobile phone or other communication equipment in schools and colleges, with exceptions, as recalled by the Ministry of National Education, 2026. According to CNIL, 2025, a connected watch may be affected if it has a SIM card or WiFi. School mode is then useful, and the internal regulations remain the reference.

Privacy. The CNIL advises checking that the manufacturer complies with the GDPR, being able to deactivate geolocation when it is not useful and explaining to the child how it works. Our article on phone geolocation gives additional references. On the wave side, theINC (2019, updated in 2025) notes that manufacturers do not communicate information on the SAR of these watches, and suggests a simple solution: turn off the watch when the child is not using it, as a precautionary principle.

Glossary

4G connected watch : watch equipped with a SIM card, which allows you to call, send messages and share your location without a phone nearby.

Security zones : perimeters defined by the parent, on certain watch models.

Mode class (school mode) : setting which limits the functions of the watch during lessons.

DAS : specific absorption rate, indicator of exposure to waves from a device.

RGPD : European regulation on the protection of personal data.

Control parental : tool that allows the parent to choose applications, screen time and internet access on their child's smartphone.

Frequently asked questions

At what age should you give a connected watch?
A connected watch becomes useful when the child begins to move around alone, often between 8 and 10 ans.
Is a connected watch enough for entry to middle school?
A connected watch may be sufficient in 6th grade if your child mainly needs to be reachable. To view the timetable or homework online, a secure smartphone becomes more practical.
Do you need a subscription for a connected watch?
Yes, a 4G watch needs a SIM card and a mobile plan to call and share its location. Bluetooth watches work without a SIM card by pairing with a smartphone.
Is the connected watch allowed at school?
A connected watch with a SIM card may be affected by the ban planned for schools and colleges, according to the CNIL. School mode limits its functions during lessons, and the internal regulations of the establishment take precedence.
How to switch from the watch to the smartphone?
The transition is most simply done in stages: a smartphone with few applications at the start, rules fixed together, then a framework which broadens with age and confidence.

Sources and references

Its first real smartphone

>